Is an agent useful or necessary for a first-time author?
There is no question an agent can get your work read at places that would be otherwise closed off to an unpublished author with no representation. And yes, an agent can be an ally in shaping your career.
But an agent can bring their own handful of complications to the process, so choose wisely. Most agents now are something of editors: You may hear, “I’m not submitting this, I just don’t think it’s that good,” on a project you adore. You may hear, “I know you love this book but I really don’t get the ending. Let’s revise it together before we consider sending it out.” You may even hear, “Probably somebody would publish this, but it’s not going to make any money, so should we really be spending our time working on this project?” They may ask you to rewrite something in a way you don’t agree with, and you may reach an impasse on a book you slaved over for years.
You have to decide if you can deal with this. You also have to get as much information as possible about an agent you want before you sign with them. Find their clients and talk to them. I’m sure most agents are fantastic, but there are stories out there about agents that do not return phone calls, give mixed messages and little feedback on an editor’s response to a manuscript (even a rejetcion often comes with positive comments, and you need to hear those), some take lengthy vacations, a week or a month off, etc, etc. Some will not submit picture books. You need to understand what to realistically expect before you sign anything with any agent.
I had an agent myself for the first book I sold, and could not have sold it without her. Greenwillow is closed to unsolicited submissions—not to mention the personal contact my agent had with my editor there which went a long way towards getting the manuscript read right away—and this all resulted in my first sale.
I later parted ways with my agent, and am now agentless. I sold my second book, this novel (which is going to be my first book, as it turns out) on my own, with help from a fellow author who thought his editor would like my book, and let me use his name when sending it in. I handled the contract myself and did not use an attorney.
So, your options, when starting out, are limited, since so many houses are closed. But no, I don’t feel an agent is absolutely necessary. I would advise knowing who you are getting involved with and honestly assessing your personality type before agreeing to any working relationship.
Everyone is a different case. Do your work, get it great, then do your research on selling it after that. And whatever happens, keep trying. If you have a good story, agented or not, it will find a home.
View all answers from: Kelly Bingham, Agents
[Back to Top]